Overall Rating and is it worth a visit: 8/10. Undecided on if it’s worth a visit again. The prices were some of the highest in Colorado for brisket which failed to impress, but would be down to give them another review at some point, as it does have the BBQ ambiance to it

Date Visited: 10/13/2020

Address: 406 Center Dr, Superior, CO 80027

Day of the Week: Friday

Time of Day: 11:15 Am. Open at 11:00 AM

Owner: Wayne & Sam Shelnutt (Husband & Wife)

Website: https://www.waynessmokeshack.com/

Number of Years in Business: Opened in 2011 and expanded in 2017. Suffered severe smoke damage on December 30th, 2021 in the Superior fire, re-opened June 6th, 2023

Number of People in Line: 15

Regional Style of BBQ: Central Texas

Total Cost: $38 with tip

Type of Wood: Oak

Type of Smoker: Commercial Electric Smokers (Need to verify)

Type of Seasoning: Salt & pepper

Best Dish: Brisket

Best Sauce: (Needs review)

Best Side: Not the mac & cheese

Interior Description: Seating for about 30-40 with long wooden tables and plenty of room to spread out. Even though it’s in the suburbs and by a large mall, it still creates a good environment and barbecue feeling/vibe when coming through the doors

Pro Tip: Skip the pork belly

Brisket

0/10 Ranking: 8 to 8.5/10

Seasoning: Salt & pepper

Description: Good flavoring and seasoning, but slightly over cooked and just a little too fatty, needing to be trimmed a little more. They don’t serve burnt ends here as everything is cut either fatty or lean in true Central Texas style

Burnt Ends – Not served here

St Louis Style Spare Ribs

0/10 Ranking: 7.5 to 8/10

Description: Good texture that melts in your mouth without losing it’s structure completely. Nice salt and pepper blend with some sugar or additional seasoning that gives off a sweetness to it. That said, it does need more flavor to put it over the top and a little sauce is required for maximum enjoyment

Pulled Pork

0/10 Ranking: 7/10 for original flavor

Description: A sweet pulled pork that doesn’t have much BBQ flavor in it. While it does have a unique taste that is enjoyable overall, it comes off too sweet and needs sauce to salvage it

Pork Belly

0/10 Ranking: 5/10

Description: Way too fatty, needing only 1/8 lb max for an order. While pork belly typically is a softer texture BBQ, this one was too mushy and too fat heavy to enjoy much of it. Wouldn’t order again

Sides – Mac & Cheese

0/10 Ranking: 6.5/10

Description: The noodles were cooked well, but the cheese flavor coming through was underwhelming. Wouldn’t order this side again.